In the world of automotive diagnostics, the choice between brands can often be overwhelming. One common question that arises is, "Which brand is better: Topdon, Autel, or Launch?" In this blog, we delve into the comparison of two prominent brands, Topdon vs Autel, to help you make an informed decision based on your specific needs.
Read our blog on Autel VS Launch here.
The Powerhouses of Automotive Diagnostic Tools:
Autel's Legacy of Innovation:
Autel has established itself as a pioneering brand in the automotive diagnostic world. With a reputation for high-quality, user-friendly, and innovative diagnostic tools, Autel has garnered trust over the years. Their longevity in the industry reflects their commitment to providing tools that deliver results. Notably, Autel is recognized for its high-end tools like the Autel MK808S, MX808, MS906 Pro, MP900E, MP900T-S and Autel Ultra.
Topdon's Technological Advancement:
On the other hand, Topdon represents a new and dynamic force in the diagnostic scan tool market. Despite being relatively new, Topdon has quickly gained attention for its advanced technology, robust yet stylish designs, smooth and efficient operation, and the delivery of precise and accurate test results. One of Topdon's standout features is its OEM-level diagnostics, showcasing the brand's commitment to excellence. The Topdon Phoenix series is particularly remarkable, offering cloud-based programming for 13 brands, a testament to their forward-thinking approach.
Comparing The Features:
To decide between Topdon and Autel, it's essential to assess your specific requirements and preferences. If you're seeking a high-end scan tool with exceptional capabilities, Topdon is a strong contender. However, if you're in the market for entry-level to mid-range professional tools, Autel offers an array of options like the:
Autel tools excel in this segment with their diverse range.
If you require a step up in functionality from these models then take a look at the Topdon Phoenix series.
When it comes to Topdon vs Autel in terms of software updates, the majority of Autel's professional scan tools offer a complimentary two-year period for updates, as do Topdon's scan tools.
The expenses associated with updating each tool vary, but in general, Topdon's updates tend to be more budget-friendly. This leads us to the conclusion that, in terms of value for money, Topdon presents a superior option.
Please note that updating your tool is not obligatory. You are not locked into a contract and have the option to refrain from updating the tool if you prefer.
Overall, both options stand out as robust and proficient tools. However, for workshops or mechanics seeking a top-tier tool, our recommendation leans towards Topdon as the preferred choice.
Comparing Similar Autel & Topdon Scan Tools:
For individuals interested in a comprehensive analysis of comparable models from both brands, we have assembled the following comparative tables:
Topdon Phoenix Smart vs Autel Maxisys MS909:
FEATURES |
||
HARDWARE: |
|
|
CPU |
Octa-core processor |
MT6761 Core 4, 2.0GHZ |
RAM |
4G |
4G |
ROM |
128G |
128G |
Battery Capacity |
15000mAH, 3.8V |
12600mAH, 3.8V |
Screen Resolution |
1536×2048 |
1280×800 |
Screen Size | 9.7" | 10.1" |
Wi-Fi | 2.4 & 5 GHz | 2.4 & 5 GHz |
Camera | Rear: 16mp | Rear: 8.0mp |
Weight | 1.66kg | 1.567 kg (3.45 lb) |
Communication | Bluetooth MaxiFlash VCI Including CANFD, DOIP, D-PDU, J2534, RP1210 |
Bluetooth MDCI Pro Including CANFD, DOIP, D-PDU, J2534, RP1210 |
Warranty | 1 year warranty | 1 year warranty |
SOFTWARE: |
|
|
Operating System | Android 7.0 / Android 10.0 | Android 10.0 |
Software updates | 2 years of free updates |
2 years of free updates |
Auto VIN | √ | √ |
FCA Secure Gateway | √ (USA version only) | √ |
Full-System Diagnostic | √ |
√ |
Component Activation | Bi-Directional Control |
Bi-Directional Control |
Enhanced Functions | √ |
√ |
Daily Maintenance Functions | 36+ Service Functions | 35+ Service Functions |
Diagnostic Topology Mapping | √ | √ |
ADAS | Adas Upgrade & Frame Kit Purchase Required |
Adas Upgrade & Frame Kit Purchase Required |
Cloud-Based Programming | 2 Brands Benz, BMW |
15 Brands (Benz, BMW, Audi, VW, SKODA, SEAT, Porche, Jaguar, Land Rover, Nissan, Subaru, Infiniti, Renault, Hyundai, Kia) |
Online FFS Activation (VW, Audi) |
√ | √ |
Mercedes-Benz DTC Guided Function | √ | √ |
DTC Guided Function (BMW, Porsche, Audi, VW) |
√ | √ |
COMPATIBLE ADD-ON TOOLS / SOFTWARE: | ||
Battery Tester | BT506 (Purchase Required) |
BTMobile Pros (Purchase Required) |
Key Programming | X | T-Ninja Box (Purchase Required) |
Tesla Software | X | Tesla Software Upgrade & Tesla Connectors (Purchase Required) |
Heavy Duty Compatibility | X |
HD Software Upgrade & HD Connector Kit |
OTHER: | ||
Software Languages | English | 15 Languages English, German, Spanish, French, Italian, Japanese, Portuguese, Russian,Polish, Turkish, Dutch, Hungarian, Chinese (Traditional), Korean, Finnish |
Upgrade Fee (End User) | $1,295 USD/Y | $795 USD/Y, $1099 USD /2Y |
Autel MK808S vs Topdon ArtiDiag Pro:
FEATURES |
||
Display |
7" |
7" |
Operating system |
Android 11.0 |
Android 7.0 |
Languages |
13+ |
10 |
Service functions |
38+ |
31+ |
Software updates |
2 years of free updates |
2 years of free updates |
Vehicle coverage |
Full car coverage for American, Asian, Australian and European vehicle makes and models, till 2022/2023 |
Over 100 makes of vehicles. You can check coverage against a certain vehicle here. |
Warranty |
1 year warranty |
1 year warranty |
Autel MS906 Pro vs Topdon Phoenix Plus
FEATURES |
||
Display |
8", 1920 x 1200 high-resolution touchscreen tablet |
10.1” Touch Screen (1280*800 Resolution) |
Operating system |
Android 10.0 OS |
Android 10.0 |
Languages | 13+ | 24 |
Special Functions | 33 | 28 |
Memory |
128GB built-in memory |
4GB RAM & 64GB On-Board Memory |
Processesor | Exynos Octa-core processor with 4G RAM | 4-core 2.0GHz Processor |
Software updates |
2 years of free updates |
2 years of free updates |
Vehicle coverage |
Compatible with U.S., Asian and European vehicles, 1996 and newer. You can check coverage against a certain vehicle here. | Over 100 makes of vehicles. You can check coverage against a certain vehicle here. |
Camera | 5 MP front camera and 16 MP rear camera |
8MP Rear Camera with AF |
Battery | 11,600 mAh | 12600 mAh/3.8V |
Warranty |
1 year warranty | 1 year warranty |
Explore Your Options:
To delve deeper into the features and functionalities of both brands, explore Topdon Scan Tools and Autel Scan Tools on our website.
Any Other Brands To Consider?
As previously mentioned, the third contender to consider is Launch. Launch is another value for money option, who produces high quality scan tools for powerful OEM-level diagnostics. To compare Autel and Launch scan tools, read our blog on here.
Get In Touch:
For inquiries or more information, feel free to reach out to us at sales@premiumdiagnostics.com.au or give us a call at 07 3180 6771. We're here to assist you in making the best decision for your automotive diagnostic needs.
Richard Autenzio
August 30, 2023
In my opinion Autel has the big name and it might have some features over Topdon but the Topdon 800BT that you sold me a few years ago has been the best tool I could have ever bought for my money. I don’t need a big name like Autel. I need value for money with a company that has good support and not one that ties me up with expensive updates. I never got the support from Autel even under warranty when one of mjne just stopped. They were not interested in me so I am no longer interested in them. My Topdon 800BT is the best little tool since sliced bread and I would recommend it to anyone through your company and your good service. If it wasn’t for you on the day I rang you for you help with a new scanner. I may not have found this very practical little gem. Thank you.